In the realm of human sources software program, SAP HR and Workday stand out as prime contenders, offering complete options for streamlining varied HR processes and managing vital knowledge. Find out how Workday HCM and SAP HR examine to find out the perfect HR software program that aligns with your corporation wants in 2023.
Jump to:
What is Workday?
Workday is a number one cloud-based software program platform designed to simplify and improve varied elements of human capital administration and monetary administration for organizations. The firm has been a pioneer in offering a unified, user-friendly resolution that seamlessly integrates core HR capabilities, reminiscent of expertise administration, payroll, advantages administration, time monitoring and workforce planning.
SEE: Oracle vs Workday: A Comparison of HR Software.
What is SAP?
SAP HR, now developed into the SAP SuccessFactors Human Experience Management Suite, takes the core ideas of HCM and enhances them to create a extra partaking and employee-focused expertise. This software program suite is designed with a deep understanding of worker wants, work kinds and motivations, offering help all through a person’s profession journey whereas empowering HR groups and enterprise leaders to drive organizational development.
1
Rippling
Rippling is the primary manner for companies to handle all of their HR, IT, and Finance — payroll, advantages, computer systems, apps, company playing cards, bills, and extra — in a single unified workforce platform. By connecting each enterprise system to 1 supply of fact for worker knowledge, companies can automate the entire guide work they usually have to do to make worker adjustments.
2
Paycor
Payroll could be a time-consuming, administrative process for HR groups. Paycor’s resolution is an easy-to-use but highly effective software that offers you time again in your day. Quickly and simply pay staff from wherever you might be and by no means fear about tax compliance once more. Key options like normal ledger integration, earned wage entry, AutoRun, worker self-service and detailed reporting simplify the method and assist make sure you pay staff precisely and on time.
3
OnPay
Payroll and HR that transfer you in the correct route. We offer you every little thing you could navigate payroll, HR, and advantages — so you possibly can preserve working your corporation easily.
Get your first month free, or be part of a demo to see every little thing we will do!
Workday HCM vs. SAP HR: Comparison desk
| Feature | Workday | SAP HR (SuccessFactors HXM Suite) |
|---|---|---|
| HRIS | Yes | Yes |
| Cloud-based | Yes | Yes |
| Analytics | Yes | Yes |
| Global compliance | Yes | Yes |
| Audit and inside controls | Yes | Yes |
| Workforce planning | Yes | Yes |
| Visa and permits administration | No | Yes |
| Recruiting and onboarding | Yes | Yes |
| Talent administration | Yes | Yes |
| Learning and improvement | Yes | Yes |
| Benefits administration | Yes | Yes |
| Payroll administration for US staff | Yes | Yes |
| International payroll | Yes | Yes |
| Time-off requests | Yes | Yes |
| Travel and expense administration | Yes | Yes |
| Employee expertise administration | Yes | Yes |
Workday and SAP pricing
Both distributors don’t publish pricing info on their web sites. The price of those methods varies relying on the dimensions of your group, the precise options and modules you want and different elements.
SEE: Looking for an worker onboarding resolution? Check out our listing of one of the best onboarding software program for small to giant companies.
Feature comparability: Workday vs. SAP
Human sources info system
Both Workday and SAP HR present strong human sources info system capabilities, providing complete options for managing worker knowledge and supporting HR capabilities.
SEE: The greatest HR software program of 2023.
While Workday’s HRIS is thought for its unified structure and seamless integration of assorted HR modules, SAP HR creates a dynamic and interesting worker expertise by way of its people-centric focus.
Global compliance
For giant enterprises working throughout a number of international locations, international compliance is paramount. Ensuring adherence to numerous worldwide labor legal guidelines, rules and knowledge privateness requirements is essential for sustaining an organization’s repute and avoiding authorized problems. As companies develop globally, their HR software program have to be able to maintaining with the evolving regulatory panorama, making international compliance a key function to think about when evaluating HR software program.
Workday and SAP HR excel in offering international compliance capabilities, catering to the wants of huge enterprises working in a number of international locations. Both firms have modules that preserve observe of regulatory adjustments and notify customers accordingly.
Learning and improvement
Both Workday and SAP HR supply spectacular studying and improvement options, with a spread of curated content material, personalised studying paths and third-party partnerships. While Workday’s studying module offers personalised content material tailor-made to every employee’s profession pursuits, SAP HR’s SuccessFactors affords studying paths for succession and improvement, enabling employers to assist staff transfer into senior-level positions.
Employee expertise administration
Employee expertise administration is an important side of contemporary HR software program. It encompasses all worker interactions with their employer, together with their work setting, relationships with colleagues and managers and entry to sources and instruments.
Workday’s platform contains options reminiscent of personalised dashboards, self-service instruments and real-time suggestions, empowering staff to take cost of their very own improvement and development. The platform additionally helps variety and inclusion efforts, enabling HR groups to create a extra inclusive and equitable work setting.
SAP HR’s SuccessFactors HXM Suite emphasizes making a dynamic and interesting worker expertise by incorporating varied instruments and options to help worker well-being, profession improvement and productiveness. The platform affords personalised studying and improvement paths, profession improvement plans and real-time suggestions to assist staff obtain their profession objectives. SuccessFactors additionally offers instruments for fostering a extra inclusive and various office, together with options reminiscent of unconscious bias coaching and variety scorecards. The platform’s mobile-responsive design lets staff entry vital info and instruments from wherever, bettering their general work expertise.
Workday professionals and cons
Pros of Workday
- Single, unified structure for seamless integration of assorted HR modules.
- User-friendly interface and mobile-responsive design for simple entry to vital info.
- Configurable platform, enabling companies to tailor the system to their particular necessities.
- Robust international compliance capabilities and superior knowledge privateness controls.
- Advanced analytics capabilities, offering helpful insights to help data-driven decision-making.
- Third-party integrations with e-learning websites, reminiscent of LinkedIn Learning, Skillsoft and Udemy for Business.
- Strong safety measures, together with role-based safety and knowledge encryption.
- Regular updates and new function releases, guaranteeing that clients have entry to the most recent capabilities.
Cons of Workday
- Some clients have complained in regards to the naming conventions used, reminiscent of referring to pages as “apps,” which some individuals discover complicated.
- There are combined critiques on the consumer interface, with some customers discovering it straightforward and others complaining that it’s outdated.
SAP professionals and cons
Pros of SAP
- SAP is a longtime firm with a robust repute.
- Comprehensive suite of HR modules masking a variety of HR capabilities.
- Strong international compliance capabilities.
- People-centric focus, with a robust emphasis on creating an attractive and dynamic worker expertise.
- Advanced analytics capabilities, offering helpful insights to help data-driven decision-making.
- Open Content Network, providing integration with varied third-party content material suppliers.
- Personalized studying and improvement paths, specializing in profession improvement and succession planning.
- Strong safety measures, together with knowledge encryption and compliance with international knowledge safety rules.
- Regular updates and new function releases, guaranteeing that clients have entry to the most recent capabilities.
Cons of SAP
- Complex system with a steeper studying curve for much less tech-savvy customers.
- Limited customizability for some options, reminiscent of efficiency administration.
- Integration with third-party methods which may generally be difficult.
Methodology
We performed in depth analysis on each platforms, gathering info from varied sources together with vendor web sites and buyer critiques. We analyzed the options and capabilities of every platform and evaluated their strengths and weaknesses, highlighting key variations and similarities.
Should your group use Workday or SAP?
When deciding between Workday and SAP, it’s vital to fastidiously consider every platform’s capabilities and contemplate your group’s particular wants. Here are some elements to think about when selecting between these two HR software program options:
Features and customization
Both Workday and SAP HR supply strong HR instruments with robust customization capabilities. However, every platform excels in several areas of HR, so it’s vital to prioritize the options that your group has the best want for. Consider which modules, reminiscent of payroll, advantages or studying and improvement, are most vital for your corporation and which platform affords the strongest capabilities in these areas.
Global compliance
If your group operates throughout a number of international locations, international compliance capabilities are essential. Both Workday and SAP HR supply robust international compliance capabilities. Consider which international locations your group operates in and whether or not the platform helps these areas.
Size of enterprise
While each Workday and SAP HR are designed for big enterprises, small companies might discover the platforms unnecessarily advanced or pricey. Consider whether or not the platform’s capabilities align together with your group’s dimension and whether or not the associated fee is justifiable for your corporation.
Integration and help
Finally, contemplate how nicely the platform integrates with different methods and software program that your group makes use of. Further, consider the standard and responsiveness of buyer help to make sure that your corporation has entry to assist when wanted.
1
Rippling
Rippling is the primary manner for companies to handle all of their HR, IT, and Finance — payroll, advantages, computer systems, apps, company playing cards, bills, and extra — in a single unified workforce platform. By connecting each enterprise system to 1 supply of fact for worker knowledge, companies can automate the entire guide work they usually have to do to make worker adjustments.
2
Paycor
Payroll could be a time-consuming, administrative process for HR groups. Paycor’s resolution is an easy-to-use but highly effective software that offers you time again in your day. Quickly and simply pay staff from wherever you might be and by no means fear about tax compliance once more. Key options like normal ledger integration, earned wage entry, AutoRun, worker self-service and detailed reporting simplify the method and assist make sure you pay staff precisely and on time.
3
OnPay
Payroll and HR that transfer you in the correct route. We offer you every little thing you could navigate payroll, HR, and advantages — so you possibly can preserve working your corporation easily.
Get your first month free, or be part of a demo to see every little thing we will do!
4
Paychex
Paychex is a cloud-based payroll administration system providing payroll, HR, and advantages administration methods for small to giant companies. Paychex covers payroll and taxes, worker 401(ok) retirement companies, advantages, insurance coverage, HR, accounting, finance and Professional Employer Organization (PEO).