Parmesan Is the Most Controversial Cheese. Here’s Why

Ask about Parmesan cheese and you will seemingly get a spread of solutions relying on who you ask and the place you might be while you ask them. That salty packet of Parmesan powder that accompanies your favourite meal package or holds courtroom on the counter of your native pizza parlor could style good, however it barely resembles the cheese as imagined by its Italian originators. Turophiles, cooks, cheesemongers and business folks discuss with actual Italian Parmesan as “Parmigiano Reggiano.” Anything else made and marketed merely as “Parmesan” cheese within the US is often of a decrease commonplace and is commonly scoffed and snickered at. 

But even actual Parmigiano Reggiano is not at all times what it appears. Fraudulent gross sales of the stuff turned so extreme that it compelled the 900-year-old business to strike again with a surprisingly trendy answer. 

There’s so much to kind out in relation to Parmesan and the numerous iterations of this extremely regarded exhausting cheese. Here’s all the things you should find out about American Parmesan vs. Parmigiano Reggiano and the way to make sure you’re getting the great things — or at the least what you paid for.

Read extra: A Cheesemonger Reveals: This Is How You Should Actually Store Your Cheese

What’s so particular about Parmigiano Reggiano?

In Italy, the place this nutty, sharp and salty cheese model originates, the time period “Parmesan” is tightly regulated, just like Champagne in France, and any cheese designated and offered as such should meet excessive requirements for manufacturing. 

The phrase Parmesan is broadly the English translation of Parmigiano Reggiano, however in America, that is about the place the similarities finish. The particulars surrounding Parmesan manufacturing are vastly totally different than in Italy. In different phrases, it is virtually fully unregulated, and people $4 blocks of “Parmesan” or (gulp) canisters of Parmesan powder you are grabbing within the dry items, cheese or dairy aisle pale compared to the actual stuff. You may even think about them a unique cheese altogether — and lots of do. 

Even although Parmesan can imply cheese of wildly various high quality, cheese offered and labeled as “Parmigiano Reggiano” within the US should come from considered one of 5 areas in Italy — Parma, Modena, Bologna, Mantua or Reggio Emilia — and cling to strict requirements because it pertains to substances, manufacturing strategies and growing old. 

Authentic Parmigiano Reggiano cheese is made utilizing solely three substances, considered one of which is milk from cows raised within the area and fed solely meals grown within the area. Unlike different Parmesans made and offered within the US, there may be additionally a large record of meals the cattle cannot be fed resembling fermented grain. Parmigiano Reggiano have to be aged for at the least a yr, however most is aged for 2 or three years and infrequently even aged longer, as much as 100 months or extra. Parmesan made within the US and different locations has no such growing old necessities.

These stringent Italian cheese legal guidelines for cheese and different DOP (Protected Designation of Origin, when translated to English) meals are the legislation of the land and had been put in place to guard the integrity of the sacred merchandise as they grew in recognition and loved exportation world wide. Other Italian DOP exports embrace Modena balsamic vinegar, San Marzano tomatoes and Parma ham. If you understand how to learn labels, they work: Spotting a DOP marking ensures you are getting an genuine meals merchandise made with requirements enforced with austerity. 

How are you aware you are getting ‘actual Parmesan’ from Italy?

For began, something marketed as Parmesan within the US is sort of undoubtedly not Parmigiano Reggiano, aka the great things. All genuine Parmigiano Reggiano is marked with pin-dot lettering that spells all of it out for you, fairly actually. ‘Parmigiano Reggiano’ shall be stamped into the rind of each wheel of cheese that comes from of the area and meets DOP requirements. Parmigiano Reggiano wheels additionally characteristic a novel alphanumeric monitoring code. Distributors right here will hack the 70- to 80-pound wheels into smaller chunks, making it more durable to learn the pin-dot letters, however the ID quantity ought to make its method to the sticker or label. You’ll additionally wish to search for the DOP label which ought to accompany each respectable portion of cheese. Shops cannot legally promote it as Parmigiano Reggiano with out these stamps of high quality. 

There’s a lot pretend cheese that they are microchipping wheels 

All that analog authentication hasn’t stopped some from attempting to beat the system with pretend variations of the actual stuff. In reality, the Parmigiano Reggiano Consortium estimated round $2 billion in pretend counterfeit gross sales per yr, which is almost as a lot as gross sales of the real article. To battle again, it began slapping silicon microchips referred to as p-Chips and QR codes on cheese wheels in 2022 to raised monitor the product and suss out imposter merchandise and counterfeit operations. The program continues to be in its infancy however the hope is that it’s going to considerably decrease the probabilities of pretend cheese ending up in your buying cart. 

Is Parmigiano Reggiano higher than Parmesan?

While it is made utilizing an identical model to the sanctioned stuff, Parmesan cheese within the US can imply many issues and is difficult to outline. Typically, cheese labeled Parmigiano Reggiano is of upper high quality (and worth) than something marked “Parmesan.” Parmigiano Reggiano is less complicated to explain because it’s all made in just about the identical method utilizing explicit substances, instruments and manufacturing strategies. 

If you do not purchase Parmigiano Reggiano, you are seemingly consuming American-made imitation Parmesan cheese. There’s nothing inherently mistaken with it; some are excellent and are available from high quality producers. But strive a chew of low-cost, generic, non-DOP Parmesan, then nibble on some genuine Parmigiano Reggiano, and you will see why it is known as the “king of cheese.” Depending on the size of time aged, this semi-hard cheese develops crunchy amino acid clusters (taste crystals) and packs a fancy umami punch with fruity, buttery, acidic and grassy notes that develop within the mouth. 

The ‘different guys’: Pecorina Romano and Grana Padano

Of course, the entire labor that goes into producing Parmigiano Reggiano makes for a pricier product than different Parmesan-style cheese, which has given rise to different Italian exhausting cheeses together with Pecorino Romano and Grana Padano. Both are made in an identical model and have like style profiles, however are made beneath much less stringent requirements and so might be crafted and offered for considerably much less. If you grate lots of cheese over your pasta each month and are eager to save lots of a couple of bucks on the grocery retailer, both one is a wonderful substitute for Parmigiano Reggiano.

But there’s nothing fairly like Parmigiano Reggiano, which stands up superbly to wines, fatty meats, good balsamic and ripe tomatoes or different fruit. Here, many consider Parmesan as one thing that is casually grated over pasta or a caesar salad. In Italy and different discerning cheese circles, you may discover the stuff served on cheese boards with apertivo to be eaten as is or served alongside fancy meats and olives.

So, end up a hunk of the actual stuff (or a complete wheel in the event you’ve obtained three grand mendacity round.) It’ll final for a really very long time if you deal with it with care, and Parmigiano Reggiano would not even must be refrigerated (!). 

Long dwell the king. 

More kitchen and residential ideas