This sponsored article is delivered to you by COMSOL.
History teaches that the Industrial Revolution started in England within the mid-18th century. While that period of sooty foundries and mills is gone, manufacturing stays important — and difficult. One promising technique to meet trendy industrial challenges is by utilizing additive manufacturing (AM) processes, comparable to powder mattress fusion and different rising strategies. To fulfill its promise of speedy, exact, and customizable manufacturing, AM calls for greater than only a retooling of manufacturing unit tools; it additionally calls for brand spanking new approaches to manufacturing unit operation and administration.
Figure 1. An 1873 illustration of coal mines and iron works in England’s West Midlands. As one of many world’s first industrialized areas, a part of this space grew to become referred to as “the Black Country” for its soot-covered panorama.
Image within the public area through Wikimedia Commons
That is why Britain’s Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) has enhanced its in-house steel powder mattress fusion AM facility with a simulation mannequin and app to assist manufacturing unit employees make knowledgeable choices about its operation. The app, constructed utilizing the Application Builder within the COMSOL Multiphysics software program, exhibits the potential for pairing a full-scale AM manufacturing unit with a so-called “digital twin” of itself.
“The model helps predict how heat and humidity inside a powder bed fusion factory may affect product quality and worker safety,” says Adam Holloway, a know-how supervisor inside the MTC’s modeling staff. “When combined with data feeds from our facility, the app helps us integrate predictive modeling into day-to-day decision-making.” The MTC mission demonstrates the advantages of inserting simulation instantly into the palms of at this time’s industrial workforce and exhibits how simulation might assist form the way forward for manufacturing.
“We’re trying to present the findings of some very complex calculations in a simple-to-understand way. By creating an app from our model, we can empower staff to run predictive simulations on laptops during their daily shifts.”
—Adam Holloway, MTC Technology Manager
Additive Manufacturing for Aerospace With DRAMA
To assist trendy British factories maintain tempo with the world, the MTC promotes high-value manufacturing all through the United Kingdom. The MTC is predicated within the historic English industrial metropolis of Coventry (Figure 2), however its focus is solely on the longer term. That is why the staff has dedicated important human and technical assets to its National Centre for Additive Manufacturing (NCAM).
Figure 2. The headquarters of the Manufacturing Technology Centre in Coventry, England.
“Adopting AM is not just about installing new equipment. Our clients are also seeking help with implementing the digital infrastructure that supports AM factory operations,” says Holloway. “Along with enterprise software and data connectivity, we’re exploring how to embed simulation within their systems as well.”
The NCAM’s Digital Reconfigurable Additive Manufacturing for Aerospace (DRAMA) mission supplies a helpful venue for this exploration. Developed in live performance with quite a few producers, the DRAMA initiative consists of the brand new powder mattress fusion AM facility talked about beforehand. With that mini manufacturing unit as DRAMA’s stage, Holloway and his fellow simulation specialists play vital roles in making its manufacturing of AM aerospace parts successful.
Making Soft Material Add Up to Solid Objects
What makes a producing course of “additive”, and why are so many industries exploring AM strategies? In the broadest sense, an additive course of is one the place objects are created by including materials layer by layer, slightly than eradicating it or molding it. A reductive or subtractive course of for producing a component could, for instance, start with a stable block of steel that’s then lower, drilled, and floor into form. An additive technique for making the identical half, in contrast, begins with empty area! Loose or smooth materials is then added to that area (below rigorously managed situations) till it kinds the specified form. That pliable materials should then be solidified right into a sturdy completed half.
Figure 3. An instance of a component produced by way of the steel powder mattress fusion course of.
Different supplies demand totally different strategies for producing and solidifying additive kinds. For instance, widespread 3D printers offered to shoppers produce objects by unspooling heat plastic filament, which bonds to itself and turns into tougher because it cools. By distinction, the steel powder mattress fusion course of (Ref. 1) begins with, as its identify suggests, a powdered steel which is then melted by utilized warmth and re-solidified when it cools. An element produced through the steel powder mattress fusion course of might be seen in Figure 3.
How Heat and Humidity Affect Metal Powder Bed Fusion
“The market opportunities for AM methods have been understood for a long time, but there have been many obstacles to large-scale adoption,” Holloway says. “Some of these obstacles can be overcome during the design phase of products and AM facilities. Other issues, such as the impact of environmental conditions on AM production, must be addressed while the facility is operating.”
Figure 4. A microscopic close-up of powdered steel grains, as used for powder mattress fusion.
For occasion, sustaining cautious management of warmth and humidity is a necessary job for the DRAMA staff. “The metal powder used for the powder bed fusion process (Figure 4) is highly sensitive to external conditions,” says Holloway. “This means it can begin to oxidize and pick up ambient moisture even while it sits in storage, and those processes will continue as it moves through the facility. Exposure to heat and moisture will change how it flows, how it melts, how it picks up an electric charge, and how it solidifies,” he says. “All of these factors can affect the resulting quality of the parts you’re producing.”
Careless dealing with of powdered steel isn’t just a risk to product high quality. It can threaten the well being and security of staff as effectively. “The metal powder used for AM processes is flammable and toxic, and as it dries out, it becomes even more flammable,” Holloway says. “We need to continuously measure and manage humidity levels, as well as how loose powder propagates throughout the facility.”
To keep correct atmospheric situations, a producer might increase its manufacturing unit’s air flow with a full local weather management system, however that may very well be prohibitively costly. The NCAM estimated that it will value practically half 1,000,000 English kilos so as to add local weather management to its comparatively modest facility. But what if they may adequately handle warmth and humidity with out including such an advanced system?
Responsive Process Management with Multiphysics Modeling
Perhaps utilizing multiphysics simulation for cautious course of administration might present an economical various. “As part of the DRAMA program, we created a model of our facility using the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) capabilities of the COMSOL software. Our model (Figure 5) uses the finite element method to solve partial differential equations describing heat transfer and fluid flow across the air domain in our facility,” says Holloway. “This enabled us to study how environmental conditions would be affected by multiple variables, from the weather outside, to the number of machines operating, to the way machines were positioned inside the shop. A model that accounts for those variables helps factory staff adjust ventilation and production schedules to optimize conditions,” he explains.
A Simulation App that Empowers Factory Staff
The DRAMA staff made their mannequin extra accessible by constructing a simulation app of it with the Application Builder in COMSOL Multiphysics (Figure 6). “We’re trying to present the findings of some very complex calculations in a simple-to-understand way,” Holloway explains. “By creating an app from our model, we can empower staff to run predictive simulations on laptops during their daily shifts.”
The app person can outline related boundary situations for the start of a manufacturing unit shift after which make ongoing changes. Over the course of a shift, warmth and humidity ranges will inevitably fluctuate. Perhaps manufacturing unit employees ought to alter the manufacturing schedule to take care of half high quality, or possibly they simply must open doorways and home windows to enhance air flow. Users can change settings within the app to check the doable results of actions like these. For instance, Figure 8 presents isothermal floor plots that present the impact that opening the AM machines’ construct chambers has on air temperature, whereas Figure 9 exhibits how airflow is affected by opening the power doorways.
A Step Toward a “Factory-Level Digital Twin”
While the present app is a crucial step ahead, it does nonetheless require staff to manually enter related knowledge. Looking forward, the DRAMA staff envisions one thing extra integral, and due to this fact, extra highly effective: a “digital twin” for its AM facility. A digital twin, as described by Ed Fontes in a 2019 submit on the COMSOL Blog (Ref. 2), is “a dynamic, continuously updated representation of a real physical product, device, or process.” It is vital to notice that even essentially the most detailed mannequin of a system is just not essentially its digital twin.
“To make our factory environment model a digital twin, we’d first provide it with ongoing live data from the actual factory,” Holloway explains. “Once our factory model was running in the background, it could adjust its forecasts in response to its data feeds and suggest specific actions based on those forecasts.”
“We want to integrate our predictive model into a feedback loop that includes the actual factory and its staff. The goal is to have a holistic system that responds to current factory conditions, uses simulation to make predictions about future conditions, and seamlessly makes self-optimizing adjustments based on those predictions,” Holloway says. “Then we could truly say we’ve built a digital twin for our factory.”
Simulation at Work on the Factory Floor
As an intermediate step towards constructing a full factory-level digital twin, the DRAMA simulation app has already confirmed its price. “Our manufacturing partners may already see how modeling can help with planning an AM facility, but not really understand how it can help with operation,” Holloway says. “We’re showing the value of enabling a line worker to open up the app, enter in a few readings or import sensor data, and then quickly get a meaningful forecast of how a batch of powder will behave that day.”
Beyond its sensible insights for producers, the general mission could provide a broader lesson as effectively: By pairing its manufacturing line with a dynamic simulation mannequin, the DRAMA mission has made your complete operation safer, extra productive, and extra environment friendly. The DRAMA staff has achieved this by deploying the mannequin the place it might do essentially the most good — into the palms of the individuals engaged on the manufacturing unit ground.